Constitutional Isomers of Alkanes — Question 8

Section 4-3 · Organic Chemistry pages 745–746

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Choose a graph invariant that actually distinguishes a pair

Both structures have formula C6H14 and a longest chain of four carbons.

A
B
  1. Count quaternary sites in A and B.

  2. Use that count to decide whether they can be identical.

  3. Why are formula and longest-chain length insufficient here?

Question 8 - Solution

Choose a graph invariant that actually distinguishes a pair

A
B

(a)

A has one quaternary site; B has none.

(b)

They cannot be identical because graph relabeling preserves every vertex degree.

(c)

Different branch distributions can share both formula and longest-chain length. A is 2,2-dimethylbutane; B is 2,3-dimethylbutane.