Constitutional Isomers of Alkanes — Question 3

Section 4-3 · Organic Chemistry pages 735–736

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Equal carbon-degree counts do not prove identity

Compare 2-methylpentane and 3-methylpentane.

A
B
  1. Count primary, secondary and tertiary carbons in each.

  2. Give the branch-to-end distances for each.

  3. Explain why the pair is constitutionally distinct despite matching site counts.

Question 3 - Solution

Equal carbon-degree counts do not prove identity

A
B

(a)

Both contain three primary, two secondary and one tertiary carbon.

(b)

A has distances 1,1,3; B has distances 1,2,2.

(c)

These distance sets cannot be changed by relabeling vertices. Degree counts are a useful filter, but do not fully specify connectivity.