Lewis Acids and Bases — Question 6

Section 3-9 · Organic Chemistry pages 681–682

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Coordination can alter polarization without giving carbon a formal plus

Consider a model adduct in which the carbonyl O donates a pair to B while the C=O double bond is retained.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Acetone
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Lewis acid
  1. Draw the new O–B connection.

  2. Assign formal charges on O, B and the carbonyl carbon.

  3. Why can coordination change carbonyl electrophilicity without a formal positive charge on carbon?

Question 6 - Solution

Coordination can alter polarization without giving carbon a formal plus

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Specified carbonyl–BF3 adduct

(a)

The O–B bond joins the carbonyl oxygen to BF3, with all original atom attachments retained.

(b)

O has bond-order sum three and one pair: +1. B has four bonds: -1. The carbonyl carbon retains four bond orders and charge zero.

(c)

Formal charge uses equal bond-electron division, whereas electrophilicity depends on actual electron distribution and orbital energies. Lewis-acid coordination can withdraw density through O without changing carbon formal charge.