Counterions — Question 9

Section 3-8 · Organic Chemistry pages 667–668

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Binding a counterion does not remove charge from the system

L is a hypothetical neutral ligand that binds M+ strongly enough to favor the right side. MB denotes an associated M+/B- pair, not a covalent neutral molecule.

MB + L <=> [M(L)]+ + B-\text{MB + L <=> [M(L)]+ + B-}

  1. Track total charge before and after ligand binding.

  2. How could this increase the availability of B- in a specified free-anion reaction pathway?

  3. Does the ligand operation itself prove a universal increase in intrinsic proton affinity?

Question 9 - Solution

Binding a counterion does not remove charge from the system

MB + L <=> [M(L)]+ + B-\text{MB + L <=> [M(L)]+ + B-}

(a)

The total remains zero: the product complex is +1 and free B- is -1.

(b)

Sequestering the cation can reduce direct association and increase the free-anion population, under the supplied model.

(c)

No. Availability, ion-pairing equilibria and intrinsic acid/base thermodynamics are distinct. Other ligand, solvent and substrate interactions must be considered before making a general claim.