Counterions — Question 4

Section 3-8 · Organic Chemistry pages 657–658

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Cancel spectators only after writing a balanced ionic equation

The displayed dilute-aqueous equation describes protonation of sodium acetate by a strong acid. Treat Na+ and Cl- as spectators in this model.

Na+ + CH3CO2- + H3O+ + Cl- -> Na+ + CH3CO2H + H2O + Cl-\text{Na+ + CH3CO2- + H3O+ + Cl- -> Na+ + CH3CO2H + H2O + Cl-}

  1. Write the net ionic equation.

  2. Identify the actual proton acceptor and donor.

  3. Why are Na+ and Cl- retained in the complete mixture even when canceled from the net equation?

Question 4 - Solution

Cancel spectators only after writing a balanced ionic equation

CH3CO2- + H3O+ -> CH3CO2H + H2O\text{CH3CO2- + H3O+ -> CH3CO2H + H2O}

(a)

.

(b)

Acetate is the acceptor; hydronium is the donor.

(c)

Cancellation removes unchanged species from the reaction bookkeeping, not from the physical solution. They remain to satisfy material and charge balances.