Leveling Effect — Question 8

Section 3-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 625–626

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Do not subtract pKa values from unrelated solvent scales

The intended reaction is HA + B giving A- + BH+ in solvent S. All values are supplied hypothetical data; S and T have different solvent environments.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain why 25 minus 22 is not a justified prediction.

  2. Use the compatible values to calculate K in S.

  3. State what must be matched when using a pKa difference.

Question 8 - Solution

Do not subtract pKa values from unrelated solvent scales

HA + B <=> A- + BH+\text{HA + B <=> A- + BH+}

(a)

The first subtraction mixes acidities measured on different solvent scales. Solvation and standard-state conventions may differ.

(b)

Using both S values, K=1019−22=10−3K=10^{19-22}=10^{-3}; reactants are favored.

(c)

Solvent, temperature and compatible standard-state definitions must match. An apparently favorable cross-solvent subtraction can give even the wrong direction.