Position of Equilibrium and Choice of Reagents — Question 10

Section 3-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 609–610

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Separate equilibrium preference from speed

Both reactions obey the supplied initial rate law v=k[HA][B]v=k[\text{HA}][\text{B}]. Compare equal initial concentrations, before appreciable depletion.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Compare their equilibrium preferences.

  2. Calculate their initial-rate ratio.

  3. Explain why pKa data alone cannot select the faster reagent.

Question 10 - Solution

Separate equilibrium preference from speed

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

The supplied transfer constants are equal, so their standard-state thermodynamic preferences are equal in this model.

(b)

v1/v2=k1/k2=104v_1/v_2=k_1/k_2=10^4. The first reaction is initially ten thousand times faster.

(c)

pKa differences give equilibrium free-energy information, not activation barriers. Steric accessibility, solvent organization and mechanism can affect rate independently.