Flow of Electron Density: Curved Arrow Notation — Question 7

Section 3-2 · Organic Chemistry pages 543–544

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Choose full arrowheads for a closed-shell transfer

The two arrows shown have full arrowheads. No radicals are present in the reactants or products.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. How many electrons does each arrow represent?

  2. Would replacing both heads by single-headed fishhooks preserve this mechanism?

  3. Explain why two arrows do not mean two protons are transferred.

Question 7 - Solution

Choose full arrowheads for a closed-shell transfer

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

NH3 + HCl -> NH4+ + Cl-\text{NH3 + HCl -> NH4+ + Cl-}

(a)

Each full-headed arrow represents an electron pair, or two electrons.

(b)

No. Fishhooks denote individual electrons and would describe different bookkeeping, generally involving radicals here.

(c)

One arrow forms the new bond and the other breaks the old bond to the same H. There is one transferred nucleus but two redistributed pairs.