Introduction to Brønsted-Lowry Acids and Bases — Question 9

Section 3-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 527–528

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Reverse the direction and reverse the roles

Analyze both directions of this one-proton-transfer equation.

CH3NH3+ + OH- <=> CH3NH2 + H2O\text{CH3NH3+ + OH- <=> CH3NH2 + H2O}

  1. Identify the acid and base in the left-to-right direction.

  2. Identify the acid and base in the right-to-left direction.

  3. Does relabeling the reverse direction imply the two directions are equally favorable?

Question 9 - Solution

Reverse the direction and reverse the roles

CH3NH3+ + OH- <=> CH3NH2 + H2O\text{CH3NH3+ + OH- <=> CH3NH2 + H2O}

(a)

Methylammonium is the acid; hydroxide is the base.

(b)

Water is the acid; methylamine is the base in the reverse direction.

(c)

No. Role identification is independent of equilibrium position. Relative strengths are needed to predict which side is favored.