Claisen Condensations — Question 5

Section 22-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 5159–5160

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Find why one alpha hydrogen may be insufficient for the standard drive

Consider a proposed ordinary self-Claisen condensation driven by deprotonation between the product carbonyls.

Ethyl 2-methylpropanoate
  1. How many hydrogens are initially on the alpha carbon?

  2. After that carbon forms a new C–C bond, how many remain there?

  3. Why does the usual product-deprotonation driving step fail?

Question 5 - Solution

Find why one alpha hydrogen may be insufficient for the standard drive

Ethyl 2-methylpropanoate

(a)

There is one alpha hydrogen.

(b)

None remain: the alpha carbon now has four carbon bonds.

(c)

No central C–H bond remains between the carbonyls to deprotonate. The standard favorable deprotonation cannot drive this proposed self-condensation; special alternative methods would need separate justification.