Reactivity of Carboxylic Acid Derivatives — Question 6

Section 21-7 · Organic Chemistry pages 4921–4922

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Identify the missing leaving group in a ketone comparison

Compare addition of a suitable nucleophile to these carbonyls.

Ketone
Ester
  1. Which structure has an alkoxy substituent that can participate in acyl substitution?

  2. What would need to leave from the ketone to give an analogous substitution?

  3. Why does the ketone normally retain the added nucleophile as an addition product?

Question 6 - Solution

Identify the missing leaving group in a ketone comparison

Ketone
Ester

(a)

The ester has the alkoxy substituent.

(b)

A methyl carbanion would have to leave from the ketone in that comparison.

(c)

A simple alkyl carbanion is a very poor leaving group, so ordinary ketone chemistry favors addition rather than this substitution.