Introduction to Carboxylic Acids — Question 7

Section 21-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 4803–4804

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Separate carbon oxidation state from formal charge

Assign C–O bonding electrons to oxygen and split C–C bonding electrons equally.

  1. What is the carboxyl carbon oxidation state?

  2. What is its formal charge in the neutral structure?

  3. Why can those two values differ?

Question 7 - Solution

Separate carbon oxidation state from formal charge

(a)

Its oxidation state is +3: +2 from C=O and +1 from C–O.

(b)

Its formal charge is zero.

(c)

Oxidation state assigns bonding electrons by electronegativity; formal charge splits covalent bonding electrons equally.