Introduction to Nucleophilic Addition Reactions — Question 9

Section 20-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 4607–4608

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Distinguish addition from ordinary acyl substitution

A student proposes nucleophilic attack on propanone followed by loss of methyl anion to regenerate C=O.

  1. What leaving-group problem occurs?

  2. What ordinary product class follows attack and protonation instead?

  3. Why does an ester require a separate mechanistic analysis?

Question 9 - Solution

Distinguish addition from ordinary acyl substitution

(a)

An unactivated methyl anion is an extremely poor leaving group, so this is not the ordinary ketone pathway.

(b)

A tetrahedral alcohol-type addition product forms, retaining both methyl groups.

(c)

An ester has a heteroatom substituent that can participate in addition-elimination under appropriate conditions.