Introduction to Nucleophilic Addition Reactions — Question 5

Section 20-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 4599–4600

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Compare steric and electronic contributions to carbonyl reactivity

Compare ordinary nucleophilic addition to ethanal and propanone under otherwise comparable conditions.

A
B
  1. Which substrate is generally less sterically hindered at carbonyl carbon?

  2. How does replacing H by an alkyl group affect electron donation?

  3. Which is generally more reactive, and why is generally preferable to always?

Question 5 - Solution

Compare steric and electronic contributions to carbonyl reactivity

A
B

(a)

Ethanal is less hindered because one substituent is H.

(b)

An extra alkyl group tends to donate electron density, reducing carbonyl electrophilicity.

(c)

Ethanal is generally more reactive; specific substituents, solvent, nucleophile and reaction conditions can alter quantitative behavior.