Introduction to Resonance — Question 2

Section 2-7 · Organic Chemistry pages 393–394

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Reject a proton transfer masquerading as resonance

A student proposes joining A and B by a resonance double-headed arrow.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
A
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
B
  1. Check whether every H remains attached to the same atom.

  2. Are these resonance contributors?

  3. What feature distinguishes this change from electron redistribution alone?

Question 2 - Solution

Reject a proton transfer masquerading as resonance

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
A
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
B

(a)

No. One H attached to carbon in A is attached to oxygen in B.

(b)

No. These are keto and enol constitutional forms, not contributors of one fixed nuclear framework.

(c)

Converting between them requires changing a sigma-bond attachment as well as pi bonding. Having the same formula is necessary but insufficient for resonance.