Assessing Relative Importance of Resonance Structures — Question 5

Section 2-11 · Organic Chemistry pages 479–480

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Symmetry can settle a ranking exactly

Assume a symmetric environment that does not distinguish the two carboxylate oxygens.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.↔\longleftrightarrowMolecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.

  1. Compare octets, charge separation and negative-charge atom types.

  2. Rank the two contributors.

  3. Would drawing one first or with its double bond vertical change that ranking?

Question 5 - Solution

Symmetry can settle a ranking exactly

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.↔\longleftrightarrowMolecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.

(a)

The criteria are identical: both have complete octets, total -1, and one negative oxygen.

(b)

They have equal importance by symmetry.

(c)

No. Page orientation and drawing order are not energetic criteria. Interchanging equivalent O labels maps one contributor into the other.