Deactivating Groups — Question 10

Section 19-8 · Organic Chemistry pages 4389–4390

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Check a nitro-group formal-charge proposal

A student erases both charges and draws the nitro nitrogen with two N=O bonds plus its ring bond.

Correct contributor to be analyzed
  1. What octet problem results?

  2. What charge pair belongs in the ordinary contributor?

  3. Does the internally neutral group cease to be electron withdrawing?

Question 10 - Solution

Check a nitro-group formal-charge proposal

Correct contributor to be analyzed

(a)

Nitrogen would have five bonding pairs, exceeding its octet.

(b)

N carries +1 and the singly bonded oxygen carries -1; the other oxygen is neutral.

(c)

No. Net neutrality does not remove the strong electron-withdrawing character of the nitro group.