Aromatic Compounds Other than Benzene — Question 3

Section 18-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 4155–4156

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Compare cationic and anionic versions of the same five-carbon ring

Use the imposed planar ground-state conjugation model.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Does the positively charged carbon contribute a lone pair?

  2. What is the pi-electron count?

  3. How does its classification differ from the six-electron anion?

Question 3 - Solution

Compare cationic and anionic versions of the same five-carbon ring

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

No. Its participating p orbital is empty in this localized cation drawing.

(b)

There are four pi electrons.

(c)

The planar four-electron system is antiaromatic in the elementary model, unlike the aromatic six-electron anion. Distortion and electronic-state changes require additional analysis.