Electrocyclic Reactions — Question 6

Section 17-9 · Organic Chemistry pages 3981–3982

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Separate a thermal symmetry prediction from an equilibrium claim

Consider the hypothetical allowed thermal closure of this same four-electron segment; no favorable equilibrium is assumed.

(3E,5E)-Octa-3,5-diene; connectivity and E/E geometry
  1. Which rotation mode applies?

  2. What ethyl relationship follows?

  3. Why does the allowed mode not establish a high cyclobutene yield?

Question 6 - Solution

Separate a thermal symmetry prediction from an equilibrium claim

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

The thermal four-electron mode is conrotatory.

(b)

The ethyl groups become trans.

(c)

Ring strain and the overall free-energy difference can favor the open diene; symmetry allowance alone does not establish equilibrium composition.