Signal Characteristics: Intensity — Question 5

Section 15-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 3299–3300

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Explain a weak symmetric carbon–carbon vibration

Consider the nearly symmetric triple-bond stretching motion.

Symmetric internal alkyne
  1. Why can its IR band be very weak?

  2. Does weak intensity prove the triple bond is absent?

  3. What corroborating evidence could resolve the ambiguity?

Question 5 - Solution

Explain a weak symmetric carbon–carbon vibration

Symmetric internal alkyne

(a)

The motion can produce little dipole change because of symmetry.

(b)

No. IR intensity depends on dipole change, not simply on whether a bond exists.

(c)

Formula, other spectroscopic evidence or a complete validated reference comparison can support the triple-bond assignment.