Hydrogen Deficiency Index: Degrees of Unsaturation — Question 9

Section 15-16 · Organic Chemistry pages 3547–3548

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Convert a protonated formula to the neutral before applying HDI

The ion is [M+H]+ from a neutral closed-shell C/H/O molecule.

C4H11O+\text{C4H11O+}

  1. Recover the neutral formula.

  2. Calculate neutral HDI.

  3. Why does applying the neutral formula directly to C4H11O give a misleading result?

Question 9 - Solution

Convert a protonated formula to the neutral before applying HDI

C4H11O+\text{C4H11O+}

(a)

Removing the added proton gives neutral C4H10O.

(b)

HDI = (8 + 2 - 10)/2 = 0.

(c)

The direct calculation gives -0.5 because the ion has an extra proton and charge. The standard neutral-valence expression requires the appropriate neutral composition.