Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
Test the ester-to-tertiary-alcohol rule with a formate ester
Use excess ethylmagnesium bromide and then workup. Apply the same addition–elimination–addition sequence as for other esters.
| Ethyl methanoate |
Identify the aldehyde intermediate after the first addition and ethoxide loss.
Draw and classify the final carbonyl-derived alcohol.
Explain precisely why the ordinary tertiary-alcohol shortcut fails here.
Question 5 - Solution
Test the ester-to-tertiary-alcohol rule with a formate ester
| Secondary alcohol exception |
(a)
The first carbonyl intermediate is propanal, because the original carbonyl H is retained.
(b)
A second ethyl adds to propanal, giving pentan-3-ol, a secondary alcohol.
(c)
A formate ester begins with H rather than a carbon substituent at the acyl carbon. Two added ethyl groups plus the retained H give a secondary, not tertiary, alcohol.