Oxidation of Phenol — Question 2

Section 13-12 · Organic Chemistry pages 2953–2954

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Compare aromaticity on the two sides of a quinone redox pair

A is hydroquinone and B is para-benzoquinone.

A
B
  1. Identify the more reduced member.

  2. Which drawing contains the aromatic benzene-like six-pi-electron ring?

  3. Explain why the two carbonyls in B do not make its ring a benzene ring with two extra double bonds.

Question 2 - Solution

Compare aromaticity on the two sides of a quinone redox pair

A
B

(a)

Hydroquinone A is the more reduced member.

(b)

A has the aromatic ring. B is a conjugated cyclic diene-dione, not an ordinary benzene-like aromatic ring.

(c)

Carbonyl pi bonds are exocyclic; the ring bonding and electron distribution differ from a six-pi-electron benzene loop. Valence must be assessed using the actual drawn bonds.