Practical Tips for Increasing Proficiency — Question 4

Section 12-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 2717–2718

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Use a counterexample to refine a hydration shortcut

The shortcut says: mercury-catalyzed hydration of any internal alkyne gives only one ketone.

Alkyne A
Alkyne B
  1. Explain why A is a poor test of the shortcut.

  2. Name the two possible ketone connectivities from B.

  3. Rewrite the shortcut to avoid an unjustified regioselectivity claim.

Question 4 - Solution

Use a counterexample to refine a hydration shortcut

B: possible product 1
B: possible product 2

(a)

But-2-yne is symmetric. Either hydration orientation gives the same ketone, butan-2-one.

(b)

Pent-2-yne can give pentan-2-one and pentan-3-one; a unique outcome should not be assumed without selectivity evidence.

(c)

Hydration gives ketones, but an unsymmetrical internal alkyne can give regioisomeric ketones. Symmetry or demonstrated selectivity is needed for a single constitutional product.