Radical Addition of HBr: Anti-Markovnikov Addition — Question 8

Section 11-10 · Organic Chemistry pages 2545–2546

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Test chain feasibility step by step instead of using only the net heat

These values illustrate why the ordinary peroxide effect is not transferred automatically from HBr to HCl or HI; they are not tabulated measurements.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Which model has both propagation steps downhill?

  2. Which step is uphill for each other model?

  3. Why is a negative sum not enough to guarantee an efficient radical chain?

Question 8 - Solution

Test chain feasibility step by step instead of using only the net heat

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

Only the HBr model has both steps downhill.

(b)

HCl has uphill H transfer; HI has uphill halogen-radical addition.

(c)

The chain must execute each step repeatedly. An unfavorable individual step can prevent efficient propagation despite a favorable net enthalpy.