Show solutionHide solution
Question 3
Repair a vicinal-product prediction for excess hydrogen bromide
The reagent is excess HBr under ionic conditions, not Br2.
| Starting material |
| Student product |
Identify the error in the student product.
Draw the usual principal product.
Explain why reagent identity matters even though both products contain two Br atoms.
Question 3 - Solution
Repair a vicinal-product prediction for excess hydrogen bromide
| Corrected product |
(a)
The student placed the Br atoms on adjacent carbons, giving a vicinal dibromide.
(b)
The expected product is the geminal dibromide 2,2-dibromobutane.
(c)
Two additions of HBr deliver two H atoms and two Br atoms with repeated Markovnikov orientation; simply counting Br atoms does not determine connectivity.