Acidity of Acetylene and Terminal Alkynes — Question 4

Section 10-3 · Organic Chemistry pages 2177–2178

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Explain why hydroxide is a poor preparative choice for acetylide formation

Use a supplied same-solvent comparison: pKaK_a(alkyne) = 25 and pKaK_a(water) = 16.

RC#CH + OH^- <=> RC#C^- + H2O\text{RC#CH + OH^- <=> RC#C^- + H2O}

  1. Estimate the proton-transfer K.

  2. Which side is favored?

  3. Why does a negative charge on hydroxide not prove sufficient base strength?

Question 4 - Solution

Explain why hydroxide is a poor preparative choice for acetylide formation

RC#CH + OH^- <=> RC#C^- + H2O\text{RC#CH + OH^- <=> RC#C^- + H2O}

(a)

K≈1016−25=10−9K\approx10^{16-25}=10^{-9}.

(b)

The neutral alkyne and hydroxide side is strongly favored.

(c)

Basicity is measured relative to the proton donor and medium. An anion can still be much too weak a base to generate a useful acetylide concentration.