Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Hybridization is a model, not a chronological movie
Methane has four equivalent C–H bonds in a tetrahedral arrangement. A student describes isolated carbon as first promoting an electron, then physically mixing orbitals, then attaching four H atoms in that exact chronological sequence.
| Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet. |
| Methane |
Solid wedge projects toward the viewer; hashed wedge projects away.
State the useful sp3 description of the final molecule.
Identify what is unsupported about the claimed sequence.
Explain how a delocalized MO description can describe the same molecule without contradicting its tetrahedral geometry.
Question 10 - Solution
Hybridization is a model, not a chronological movie
| Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet. |
| Methane |
(a)
Four equivalent carbon sp3 hybrids overlap with four H 1s orbitals in tetrahedral directions, providing a localized model of four sigma bonds.
(b)
Promotion and hybridization are explanatory constructions, not proof of a measured time sequence or a chemical mechanism. Atomic basis functions are combined mathematically to describe the bonded state.
(c)
An MO treatment uses orbitals extending over the molecule instead of four exclusively localized bond orbitals. Both are models of the same electronic structure and must be consistent with molecular symmetry and observations. A change in orbital representation does not change the positions of the nuclei.