Atomic Orbitals — Question 7

Section 1-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 123–124

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Reading the signs on a p orbital

The two lobes of a real 2px2p_x wavefunction are marked with opposite signs.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

Schematic lobe contours; the dashed line is an edge view of a plane.

  1. Do the signs represent positive and negative electrical charge?

  2. Locate the nodal plane relative to the x axis.

  3. Explain what happens to the probability density if the sign of the entire wavefunction is reversed.

Question 7 - Solution

Reading the signs on a p orbital

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

No. They are algebraic phases of the wavefunction. An electron has the same negative charge regardless of the lobe in which it is detected.

(b)

The nodal plane is the yz plane through the nucleus, perpendicular to x. The wavefunction and probability density vanish on that plane for this orbital.

(c)

Probability density is |ψ|2|\psi|^2. Replacing ψ\psi by −ψ-\psi leaves |ψ|2|\psi|^2 unchanged. Only relative phase matters when combining orbitals; the overall sign of one isolated wavefunction is arbitrary.