Atomic Orbitals — Question 5

Section 1-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 119–120

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Separating Pauli exclusion from energy ordering

Boron has valence configuration 2s22p12s^2 2p^1, but a student draws the two 2s arrows as shown.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Identify the error.

  2. Repair the diagram while retaining its orbital occupancies.

  3. State the maximum occupancy of one spatial orbital and the required spin relationship.

Question 5 - Solution

Separating Pauli exclusion from energy ordering

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

Two electrons in the same spatial orbital cannot have the same spin. The proposed 2s pair violates Pauli exclusion.

(b)

Reverse one 2s arrow. Keep one electron in a 2p orbital, giving a valid ground-state valence diagram.

(c)

A spatial orbital can contain at most two electrons, and those two have opposite spin projections. The fact that other p orbitals are empty does not excuse a same-spin pair in 2s; Pauli exclusion applies to every orbital independently.