Show solutionHide solution
Question 3
A missing-lone-pair error in methanol
The student says the drawing is a complete Lewis structure of neutral methanol. All C–H bonds in are understood.
| Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet. |
| Student drawing |
Count the electrons represented and compare with the formula’s budget.
Repair the drawing.
Explain the difference between a permissible abbreviated structural formula and a claimed complete Lewis structure.
Question 3 - Solution
A missing-lone-pair error in methanol
| Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet. |
| Corrected |
(a)
Methanol has valence electrons. Five single bonds represent ten electrons, and the one shown lone pair adds two: only twelve are represented.
(b)
Add a second oxygen lone pair. Oxygen then has two bond pairs and two lone pairs, eight electrons around it; the total is fourteen.
(c)
An ordinary structural formula may omit nonbonding electrons when understood by convention. A complete Lewis representation must account for them. The error is not the existence of an abbreviated formula; it is calling an incomplete electron inventory complete.