The Structural Theory of Matter — Question 2

Section 1-2 · Organic Chemistry pages 33–34

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Repairing a pentavalent carbon

The proposed drawing is intended to be a neutral, closed-shell hydrocarbon with only single bonds.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Proposed neutral drawing

Deliberately incorrect proposal: inspect the central atom.

  1. Identify the valence error.

  2. Repair it by changing only one hydrogen subscript, keeping all C–C connections.

  3. Give the repaired formula and explain why adding a formal charge is not an appropriate shortcut here.

Question 2 - Solution

Repairing a pentavalent carbon

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Corrected structure

The central carbon now has exactly four single bonds.

(a)

The central has three C–C single bonds and two C–H bonds: five bonds at a second-row carbon.

(b)

Change central to . Its four single bonds then give normal carbon valence. The three terminal methyl groups plus one central H give .

(c)

A charge label does not remove the ten electrons implied around a five-bond carbon. The problem specifies an ordinary neutral closed-shell hydrocarbon; correcting the hydrogen count restores that model.