Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Cloudiness is not proof of molecular dissolution
After shaking an oil–water mixture, it becomes cloudy. On standing, two layers reappear. No chemical reaction occurs.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Droplets are schematic phase domains, not drawings of individual oil molecules.
Explain the likely origin of the cloudiness.
Distinguish a temporary emulsion from a molecular solution.
Explain why “like dissolves like” is a useful heuristic but not a complete thermodynamic criterion.
Question 9 - Solution
Cloudiness is not proof of molecular dissolution
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a)
Shaking disperses small oil droplets through water. Droplets scatter light, causing cloudiness; later coalescence restores distinct layers.
(b)
An emulsion contains dispersed domains of one phase within another. A molecular solution distributes solute at molecular or ionic scale in a single phase. Shaking can improve dispersion without creating complete mutual solubility.
(c)
Similar interactions often favor mixing, but equilibrium depends on free energy: interactions being broken and formed, entropy, temperature, composition, and phase structure. The heuristic cannot replace that full balance or prove that a cloudy sample has dissolved.