Solubility — Question 1

Section 1-13 · Organic Chemistry pages 251–252

Show solutionHide solution

Question 1

One OH group does not erase a growing hydrocarbon region

Compare the two neutral alcohols in water at the same temperature.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
A: ethanol
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
B: 1-hexanol
  1. Identify the hydrophilic and relatively hydrophobic regions.

  2. Predict which has greater compatibility with water and justify without treating the OH group as an absolute solubility guarantee.

  3. Explain why an exact solubility cannot be calculated from the drawings alone.

Question 1 - Solution

One OH group does not erase a growing hydrocarbon region

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
A: ethanol
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
B: 1-hexanol

Both molecules have one OH group, but their nonpolar portions differ substantially.

(a)

The OH region can donate and accept hydrogen bonds with water. The hydrocarbon region interacts mainly through dispersion and does not replace water’s hydrogen-bond contacts in the same way.

(b)

Ethanol has the smaller nonpolar region relative to its one OH group and is more compatible with water. Extending the hydrocarbon chain while keeping only one OH generally lowers aqueous compatibility in this homologous comparison.

(c)

Quantitative solubility depends on the complete free-energy balance, temperature, phase behavior and molecular interactions. Functional-group counting is a useful guide, not a numerical solubility law or a universal carbon-count cutoff.