Dipole Moments and Molecular Polarity — Question 9

Section 1-11 · Organic Chemistry pages 227–228

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Zero average orientation is not zero molecular dipole

A dilute gas of polar molecules has no applied electric field and no preferred orientation.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

Arrows represent entire molecular dipoles; molecular structures are intentionally abstracted.

  1. Explain why its average dipole vector can be zero.

  2. Does that make each molecule nonpolar?

  3. For identical rigid molecules of dipole magnitude μ0\mu_0, compare ⟨𝝁⟩\langle\boldsymbol\mu\rangle with ⟨|𝝁|2⟩\langle|\boldsymbol\mu|^2\rangle.

Question 9 - Solution

Zero average orientation is not zero molecular dipole

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

Random orientations give equal statistical weight to opposite directions, so vector components cancel in the ensemble average.

(b)

No. Each molecule still has its own nonzero permanent dipole. Averaging orientations is different from cancellation among bonds within one molecule.

(c)

Isotropy gives ⟨𝝁⟩=𝟎\langle\boldsymbol\mu\rangle=\mathbf0, while fixed magnitude gives ⟨|𝝁|2⟩=μ02>0\langle|\boldsymbol\mu|^2\rangle=\mu_0^2>0. Squaring after averaging and averaging the square are different operations. This distinction matters when relating molecular polarity to macroscopic response.