Introduction to Organic Chemistry — Question 2

Section 1-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 13–14

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Identical molecules from different sources

Purified samples A and B both contain only ethanol with identical isotopic composition. Both are measured at the same temperature and pressure.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Predict whether their equilibrium boiling points differ because of origin.

  2. A laboratory finds a small difference. Give two experimental explanations to investigate.

  3. Evaluate the claim “natural ethanol has different covalent bonds.”

Question 2 - Solution

Identical molecules from different sources

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Ethanol in both samples

One molecular structure represents both purified samples.

(a)

Their equilibrium boiling points should agree within experimental uncertainty. Molecular identity and conditions, not the production route, determine this property.

(b)

Investigate unequal pressure or calibration first; also test the premise of purity, for example water contamination. If either premise fails, the comparison is no longer between identical pure substances under identical conditions.

(c)

The claim is false under the stated assumptions. Both samples have the same connectivity and electronic structure. Origin can affect impurities or isotope distributions in real samples, but those possibilities have explicitly been excluded here.