Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Choose a model that addresses the observable
You must explain three observations: methane has four nearly tetrahedral C–H directions; oxygen has two unpaired electrons; and benzene has six equivalent C–C links. Available tools are a localized sigma/hybrid description, MO filling with spin, and resonance or delocalized pi orbitals.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Match each observation to a suitable tool and give the key reasoning.
Explain why using different tools for these observations is not a claim that each molecule has several incompatible electronic realities.
Question 10 - Solution
Choose a model that addresses the observable
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Use a tetrahedrally directed localized sigma basis for methane. Use degenerate pi-star occupation and Hund filling for the two unpaired O electrons. Use resonance or a ring-wide pi description for equivalent benzene links.
(b) Analysis
The tools emphasize different properties and levels of approximation of one electronic system. A localized bond drawing is useful for connectivity but may omit spin or delocalization; agreement with one observable does not guarantee that it answers every other question.
Check and interpretation
Choose the representation for the property being explained, and retain its stated limitations.