The Molecular Orbital Model — Question 10

Section 9-2 · Chemistry pages 1585–1586

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Recognize an arbitrary orbital phase convention

One basis choice uses ϕA\phi_A and ϕB\phi_B with matching signs in their facing lobes, and the bonding MO is proportional to ϕA+ϕB\phi_A+\phi_B. Now redefine ϕ̃B=−ϕB\widetilde\phi_B=-\phi_B without changing the physical orbital.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Rewrite the same bonding MO in the new convention.

  2. Explain why the words plus combination do not always identify a bonding MO without checking the facing phases.

Question 10 - Solution

Recognize an arbitrary orbital phase convention

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The identical physical function is proportional to ϕA−ϕ̃B\phi_A-\widetilde\phi_B. Changing the basis sign changes the written coefficient sign.

(b) Analysis

Constructive interference between the actual facing lobes determines the bonding enhancement. An arbitrary overall sign of a basis function changes algebraic notation but does not change measurable density.

Check and interpretation

Electron density depends on the complete wave function, not on a standalone plus sign in a formula.