Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Use equivalent bonds to identify a localization limit
A supplied nitrate-ion description has three equal N–O distances. One localized Lewis contributor assigns one N=O and two N–O links. Assume equal environments for the three oxygens.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Why is one frozen unequal-bond contributor incomplete as a description of the observed equivalence?
What broader electron-distribution idea is needed?
Question 10 - Solution
Use equivalent bonds to identify a localization limit
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
A literal fixed assignment would distinguish one N–O link from the other two, whereas the supplied geometry treats all three equally. The single contributor is useful bookkeeping but does not by itself express that equivalence.
(b) Analysis
A delocalized description, represented at this level by equivalent resonance contributors, distributes the bonding over all three links. It does not require the molecule to jump between separate fixed single/double-bond species.
Check and interpretation
This identifies a limitation of strict localization; detailed resonance construction is treated in its own section.