Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
Do not infer local ionicity from a zero molecular dipole
A supplied linear X–A–X molecule has two identical polar bonds with equal opposing dipole contributions. Its total permanent dipole is zero.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Would substituting the molecular dipole into a diatomic ionic-percentage formula determine the character of either bond?
Explain what information is lost by the vector cancellation.
Question 7 - Solution
Do not infer local ionicity from a zero molecular dipole
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
No. The diatomic formula assumes one charge-separation axis for one pair. Here the zero is the sum of two nonzero contributions, so it cannot be used as the local bond dipole.
(b) Analysis
Cancellation removes directional information about the separate contributions from the net observable. One would need an additional bond model or local electron-density information to assign bond-level character.
Check and interpretation
Molecular nonpolarity and nonpolar individual bonds are different statements.