Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Compare two oxidation-state proposals through full cycles
Two hypothetical routes form charge-neutral solids of the same metal. For MX, preparation costs +700 and lattice formation contributes -1000 kJ/mol. For MX, preparation costs +1900 and lattice formation contributes -2150 kJ/mol. Each preparation includes the appropriate quantity of the elemental X reference.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate both formation enthalpies per mole of metal.
For with the specified elemental reference, calculate the enthalpy and assess the claim that the larger lattice magnitude alone selects MX.
Question 9 - Solution
Compare two oxidation-state proposals through full cycles
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
MX gives kJ/mol; MX gives kJ/mol. Both values are normalized to one mole of metal.
(b) Analysis
The conversion enthalpy is kJ/mol. The larger lattice release for MX does not fully offset its extra preparation cost. Enthalpy alone also does not settle equilibrium without entropy and conditions.
Check and interpretation
Compare balanced processes with consistent elemental references, not unrelated isolated terms.