Resonance — Question 10

Section 8-12 · Chemistry pages 1525–1526

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Estimate stabilization against a stated localized reference

A hypothetical localized three-double-bond ring model predicts hydrogenation to a specified saturated product at -360 kJ/mol. Actual benzene hydrogenation to the same product and reference states is represented here by a rounded -210 kJ/mol. Assume the model and actual comparisons use the same hydrogen amount.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Infer how far below the localized-reference energy the benzene reactant lies.

  2. Why should this be described as a reference-model estimate rather than a direct measurement of resonance contributors?

Question 10 - Solution

Estimate stabilization against a stated localized reference

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Let product energy be P. The localized reactant has energy P+360P+360 and benzene has P+210P+210, so benzene is lower by 150 kJ/mol relative to that reference.

(b) Analysis

The localized reference is a constructed comparison, not a separately isolated resonance contributor. Differences in the reference assumptions affect the estimate. The cycle supports stabilization relative to the stated model, not a literal equilibrium between Kekule drawings.

Check and interpretation

The reaction endpoints and hydrogen amount must match for the subtraction to have this meaning.