Show solutionHide solution
Question 3
Use nuclear connectivity to distinguish resonance from isomerism
Compare two proposed pairs: Pair A moves a double bond and lone pair between equivalent links while every nucleus stays fixed; Pair B changes CHCHOH into CHOCH.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Which pair can represent resonance contributors, and which changes constitutional connectivity?
List the quantities that valid resonance contributors must conserve.
Question 3 - Solution
Use nuclear connectivity to distinguish resonance from isomerism
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Pair A can represent resonance if its electron count and valences remain valid. Pair B changes which atoms are neighbors and represents constitutional isomers, not resonance.
(b) Analysis
Valid contributors conserve nuclear identities and positions/connectivity, total electron number, net charge and the species being described. They differ in electron allocation, including bond orders, lone pairs and formal-charge locations.
Check and interpretation
Having the same molecular formula is not sufficient for a resonance relationship.