Exceptions to the Octet Rule — Question 6

Section 8-11 · Chemistry pages 1497–1498

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Count an expanded shell in a gas-phase phosphorus structure

For molecular PCl5_5(g), use P = 5 and Cl = 7. Draw five P–Cl single bonds and complete each terminal Cl octet.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Verify the total valence count and the number of electrons counted around P.

  2. Distinguish expanded-octet bookkeeping from a literal measurement of ten electrons belonging exclusively to phosphorus.

Question 6 - Solution

Count an expanded shell in a gas-phase phosphorus structure

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The total is 5+5(7)=405+5(7)=40. Five bonds use ten electrons and fifteen Cl lone pairs use thirty. The conventional shell count around P is ten.

(b) Analysis

The shell count includes shared bonding electrons in full. It is not an exclusive atomic population extracted from electron density. A more detailed bonding model is needed to describe how the density is actually distributed.

Check and interpretation

The prompt specifies the gas-phase molecule; phase-dependent ionic structures are a separate question.