Exceptions to the Octet Rule — Question 3

Section 8-11 · Chemistry pages 1491–1492

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

State the physical scope of a deficient monomer model

For an isolated BeCl2_2 monomer, use Be = 2 and Cl = 7 and a Cl–Be–Cl single-bond skeleton. Complete the chlorine octets.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Count the electrons surrounding Be and verify the full valence total.

  2. Why should this isolated-monomer drawing not automatically be taken as the complete structure of solid BeCl2_2?

Question 3 - Solution

State the physical scope of a deficient monomer model

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The total is sixteen. Two bonds use four electrons and the two Cl atoms have twelve nonbonding electrons. Be is surrounded by only four bonding electrons.

(b) Analysis

Condensed substances can adopt associated or extended structures with different coordination. A monomer Lewis diagram describes the stipulated particle; it does not alone establish the structure of every phase. Structural evidence is needed for the solid.

Check and interpretation

A phase or aggregation assumption is part of the model, not a minor label.