Lewis Structures — Question 3

Section 8-10 · Chemistry pages 1471–1472

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Repair a charge-separated carbonyl sketch

Use formal charge FC=V−N−B/2FC=V-N-B/2, where V is neutral-atom valence count, N is nonbonding electrons and B is bonding electrons. A trial CH2_2O structure has two C–H single bonds, one C–O single bond and three O lone pairs; C has none. Use H = 1, C = 4 and O = 6.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the trial formal charges and identify the incomplete octet.

  2. Move an existing O lone pair into bonding to obtain the usual neutral structure, and recalculate the charges.

Question 3 - Solution

Repair a charge-separated carbonyl sketch

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

C has three bonds and no lone pairs: FCC=4−0−6/2=+1FC_C=4-0-6/2=+1, with only six surrounding electrons. O has FCO=6−6−2/2=−1FC_O=6-6-2/2=-1. Each H has zero formal charge.

(b) Analysis

Form a C=O double bond, leaving two O lone pairs. Now FCC=4−0−8/2=0FC_C=4-0-8/2=0 and FCO=6−4−4/2=0FC_O=6-4-4/2=0. The twelve-electron total is preserved and carbon gains an octet.

Check and interpretation

Formal-charge neutrality of the entire drawing alone does not guarantee every atom has an appropriate shell.