Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Check whether electron transfer alone pays the energy cost
For hypothetical isolated gas atoms, removing an electron from A costs 480 kJ/mol and attaching it to B releases 300 kJ/mol. Subsequent association of the ions releases 250 kJ/mol.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate the net change for creating separated ions, then for completing association.
Explain why ionic bonding cannot be justified only by saying that atoms seek full shells.
Question 8 - Solution
Check whether electron transfer alone pays the energy cost
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Separated-ion formation costs kJ/mol. Including association gives kJ/mol, so the complete specified path is stabilizing.
(b) Analysis
Electron configurations help organize patterns, but energy accounting explains stability. A full-shell description alone does not pay the ionization cost; attraction between charges and other environmental terms can be decisive.
Check and interpretation
All three values refer to compatible stages of the same hypothetical molar process.