Polyelectronic Atoms — Question 8

Section 7-9 · Chemistry pages 1201–1202

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Remove duplicated electron repulsion from an energy sum

In a hypothetical two-electron bookkeeping model, each electron has one-electron kinetic-plus-nuclear contribution h = -25 eV, and the pair repulsion is J = +10 eV. A reported orbital-like value includes the full interaction with the other electron: ϵi=h+J\epsilon_i=h+J.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find total energy by counting physical contributions once.

  2. Compare with ϵ1+ϵ2\epsilon_1+\epsilon_2 and identify the correction.

Question 8 - Solution

Remove duplicated electron repulsion from an energy sum

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Total energy is h1+h2+J=−25−25+10=−40h_1+h_2+J=-25-25+10=-40 eV.

(b) Analysis

Each orbital-like value is -15 eV, so their sum is -30 eV. It counts J twice. Subtract one J to get −30−10=−40-30-10=-40 eV. Thus orbital-energy sums are not automatically total energies.

Check and interpretation

The model illustrates bookkeeping only; a full electronic-structure method has additional formal details.