Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
Separate penetration effects from orientation effects
In a spherically symmetric central-field approximation for a multi-electron atom, 3s penetrates the core more than 3p. The three real 3p orientations are related by rotations. No external field is present.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Explain why 3s and 3p can have different energies.
Should rotating 3p from the x direction to the y direction change its energy in this approximation?
Question 5 - Solution
Separate penetration effects from orientation effects
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Different radial penetration changes how the electron samples screened nuclear attraction. Thus different l values within the same n can have different energies.
(b) Analysis
No. A spherical central potential has no preferred spatial direction. Rotated members of the same subshell remain degenerate in this approximation. An external field or nonspherical environment can change that conclusion.
Check and interpretation
This is a statement about the specified orbital approximation, not every many-electron term or molecular environment.