Orbital Shapes and Energies — Question 5

Section 7-7 · Chemistry pages 1155–1156

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Use penetration to explain a supplied energy ordering

For a particular multi-electron atom, calculations show that among n = 3 orbitals, 3s penetrates the core most, then 3p, then 3d. Greater core penetration experiences less screening and stronger nuclear attraction.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Predict the qualitative energy ordering under these assumptions.

  2. Why is this a statement about a specified atom rather than a universal ordering of every orbital with every n?

Question 5 - Solution

Use penetration to explain a supplied energy ordering

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The more penetrating orbital is stabilized more, giving E(3s)<E(3p)<E(3d)E(3s)<E(3p)<E(3d) for the supplied situation.

(b) Analysis

Cross-shell ordering also depends on principal size, occupancy, nuclear charge and electron interactions. The penetration argument for one shell does not prove a fixed ordering across all atoms and ions.

Check and interpretation

The prompt supplies the physical trend; no orbital energy is inferred from a lobe sketch alone.